by James Craig Green
I was recently reminded of Rand's assertion in this essay that:
1. ...a society that sets up a conflict between its edicts and the requirements of man's nature - is...but a mob held together by institutionalized gang rule and,
2. ...a government (that) holds a monopoly of legal use of physical force is the best way to prevent or limit this.
I agree with the first, but not the second.
A government that enjoys a legal monopoly of force CANNOT protect individual rights because it must be based on their violation against innocents. Any individual or organization claiming to exercise authority over those who have not accepted it is a thief, mugger, or tyrant. "Consent of the Governed" either means individual by individual, or nothing.
However, I am willing to tolerate such an organization -- if its purpose CAN BE limited to the protection of individual rights -- something no government in history has achieved. Accordingly, I accept the U.S. Constitution, with all 27 amendments as written (but not as interpreted by the Supreme Court) as the most successful and elegant attempt to reach this lofty goal.
Rand's "legal monopoly of force to protect individual rights" is often compared to the libertarian "anarchy" of Murray Rothbard. Ironically, those who claim ideas in their heads to be the most objective and rational, sometimes resort to emotional oversimplifications and logical fallacies to make their case. If you define "anarchy" as chaos and destruction, it is easy, by circular logic, to conclude it is.
It is possible that either of these, or neither, may prove themselves to be a viable future alternative to today's massive, unsustainable, Leviathan State. But, it is just as likely that some solution none of our dead mentors conceived will prove to be superior. Empiricism (unsubsidized science, technology and business) has often produced beneficial social changes which no prior generation could conceive.
For now, it is paramount to reduce existing governments drastically in size and scope toward protection and away from plunder. If, at some future time when today's monopolistic government has made great strides toward this transformation, old objectivists and libertarians may sit around in rocking chairs to regale their grandchildren with stories. But, I wouldn't be surprised to find that by then, a form of social organization we cannot yet conceive has taken the spotlight, for better or worse. I think it will be for the better, because of the self-directed productivity that resides in most of us when not seduced away by government freebies paid for by the plunder of innocents.
Personally, I choose to let neither Ayn Rand nor Murray Rothbard set the bounds of my future thinking, though both greatly contributed to my life in important ways. Like other goods and services produced by markets, people and property protection are most likely to be maximized when innovations are not inhibited by such an anti-human ethic as top-down force, no matter what soothing words are used to describe it.
I could be wrong, because I am not omniscient.
Neither was Rand, Rothbard, nor any other of my imperfect heroes.
Craig Green's blog discusses history, philosophy and economics from a free market perspective. See Craig's bio, premises, archives and links in the right column. From 2011, April's "Unchain the Builders" series begins with "Unchain The Builders 1," each linked to the other articles. March's "Subordinate Acts" is Craig's article on the U.S. Constitution. Also see March's LIFEPOWER articles from the 1990's. Anyone can comment without subscription, but leave email if you want to keep abreast.
Showing posts with label Ayn Rand. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ayn Rand. Show all posts
Sunday, September 18, 2011
Tuesday, May 24, 2011
CRAIG'S SEVEN PREMISES
My first premise is that people are inherently selfish.
This was a necessary characteristic of each and every one of your ancestors, as proven by your existence. It is a good thing if not taken to the extremes of narcissism or aggressive pursuits that harm others. But, respect for others does not include allowing yourself to be manipulated, sacrificing yourself for others, or accepting other demands on your life without your consent. The Dutch philosopher Spinoza and others called this selfish struggle of life CONATUS.
Ayn Rand, in The Virtue of Selfishness, wrote:
Since nature does not provide man with an automatic form of survival, since he has to support his life by his own effort, the doctrine that concern with one's own self interest is evil means that man's desire to live is evil - that man's life, as such, is evil. No doctrine could be more evil than that.I don't claim that all people act selfishly all the time, but it is a prudent, default assumption until proven wrong in individual cases. To clarify, I include mutual, non-monetary benefits that both parties to a friendship or association gain to be evidence of a healthy, selfish relationship, without contradiction. I do not distinguish between "selfish" and "self-interest," as some people do.
My second premise, as discussed in my mid-nineties LifePower articles SEEK JOY, CREATE VALUE and LIFE IS EGOCENTRIC, is that honestly self-aware and self-motivated people make the most productive, supportive and happiest friends, neighbors, associates and yes, even citizens - when left alone to pursue their selfish interests - as long as they do not deny or restrict the equal right of others to pursue theirs.
My third premise is that people own themselves, which means they have a right to their lives, liberty and property, which deserve to be protected against aggressive force, theft or fraud. These rights are not granted by any human authority, but are inherent in human nature, as most powerfully described by the English philosopher John Locke in a section called OF PROPERTY in Chapter II of his TWO TREATISES OF GOVERNMENT. Locke's concept of human rights was one of the primary inspirations for the American Declaration of Independence. I draw a sharp distinction between aggressive and defensive force.
My fourth premise is that government as we know it (a legal but coercive monopoly of force against innocents) works against most of its citizens when it exceeds its proper authority to protect individual rights - the only legitimate justification for its collective force. Please read the section, WHAT IS LAW? in Frederic Bastiat's 1850 masterpiece, THE LAW. Government cannot protect your property by giving it to others.
My fifth premise is while coercive, monopolistic government exists, its purpose should be strictly limited to the protection of people and their property, including police and/or defensive military and impartial courts. For the federal government, other duties authorized by the U.S. Constitution would be included as part of necessary goals and limitations for much less oppressive government toward which the current government should gravitate. See my article SUBORDINATE ACTS.
My sixth premise is that coercive, monopolistic government should not be involved in the economy at all, except for adjudicating disputes in civil cases, since it almost always makes the economy worse, not better. See CHAPTER 1 of Henry Hazlitt's ECONOMICS IN ONE LESSON. Coercive government's complete ignorance of 1) market economics and 2) the productive nature of the unsubsidized private sector is both striking and unconscionable for an organization that claims to represent the people. See CHAPTER 3 of FOR A NEW LIBERTY by Murray Rothbard to understand the nature of coercive, monopolistic government.
My seventh premise is that about 90 percent of knowledge is dogma. This idea began as a joke several years ago, due to my frustration to make sense of large inconsistencies I found in so many fields, like philosophy, science, religion, law, politics, economics, dog training and both contemporary and alternative medicine. In every field of knowledge I have studied, there are far more unknowns than knowns. An honest search for more and better knowledge must include the attitude that what we know today is only our best current approximation, to be improved by further knowledge gained later. Please spend some time at the SIMANEK PAGES, for which you will be richly rewarded. The four points below are a sample of Donald Simanek's summary and conclusions page:
- Logic (and mathematics) alone tell us nothing about the natural world.
- Through our senses we form a mental picture of what we call the "real world". It's just a name, and inquiry into the "reality" of this world or our perceptions is futile philosophizing.
- This "real world" shows regular patterns and behavior, so we can express these as "things" and "laws", often with mathematical precision.
- The reliable regularity of natural laws allows us to do science. We can't even imagine a universe that had no regularity at all, or one whose behavior unexpectedly changed in unpredictable ways without warning of any kind.
I CALL THESE PREMISES BECAUSE human knowledge is so often dominated by arrogance, vanity, chauvinism, uncritical repetition and dishonesty. Premises sometimes called self-evident "truths" are just assumptions with which to begin investigations. Most philosophies, professions, religions, sciences and other bodies of knowledge are often dominated by dogma and blind conformity to authority or custom, which people adopt to avoid changing existing beliefs. Changing beliefs is often a sign of maturity, unless done in a haphazard, unthinking manner. As I understand the current science of sub-atomic particles, that big rock you and others see is mostly empty space.
Uncertainty is the beginning of knowledge.
Certainty is the end. - James Craig Green
Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic - Arthur C. Clarke
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)